Bed bugs: They crawl, bite, and baffle scientists
By New York Times News Service
Friday, 10 Sep 2010
Bed bugs in the lab of Stephen Kells, a University of Minnesota entomologist, in St. Paul, Minn
Don?t be too quick to dismiss the common bedbug as merely a pestiferous six-legged blood-sucker.
Think of it, rather, as Cimex lectularius, international arthropod of mystery.
In comparison to other insects that bite man, or even only walk across man?s food, nibble man?s crops or bite man?s farm animals, very little is known about the creature whose Latin name means - go figure - ?bug of the bed.? Only a handful of entomologists specialize in it and until recently it has been low on the government?s research agenda because it does not transmit disease. Most study grants come from the pesticide industry and ask only one question: What kills it?
But now that it?s The Bug That Ate New York, Not to Mention Other Shocked American Cities, that may change.
This month, the Environmental Protection Agency and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued a joint statement on bedbug control. However, it was not a declaration of war nor a plan of action. It was an acknowledgment that the problem is big, a reminder that federal agencies mostly give advice, plus some advice: try a mix of vacuuming, crevice-sealing, heat and chemicals to kill the things.
It also noted, twice, that bedbug research ?has been very limited over the past several decades.?
Ask any expert why the bugs disappeared for 40 years, why they came roaring back in the late 1990s, even why they don?t spread disease, and you hear one answer: ?Good question.?
?The first time I saw one that wasn?t dated 1957 and mounted on a microscope slide was in 2001,? said Dini M. Miller, a Virginia Tech Co*kroach expert who has added bedbugs to her repertoire.
The bugs have probably been biting our ancestors since they moved from trees to caves. The bugs are ?nest parasites? that fed on bats and cave birds like swallows before man moved in.
That makes their disease-free status even more baffling.
(The bites itch, and can cause anaphylactic shock in rare cases, and dust containing feces and molted shells has triggered asthma attacks, but these are all allergic reactions, not disease.)
Bats are sources of rabies, Ebola, SARS and Nipah virus. And other biting bugs are disease carriers - mosquitoes for malaria and West Nile, ticks for Lyme and babesiosis, lice for typhus, fleas for plague, tsetse flies for sleeping sickness, kissing bugs for Chagas. Even non-biting bugs like houseflies and Co*kroaches transmit disease by carrying bacteria on their feet or in their feces or vomit.
But bedbugs, despite the ick factor, are clean.
Actually it is safer to say that no one has proved they aren?t, said Jerome Goddard, a Mississippi State entomologist.
But not for lack of trying. South African researchers have fed them blood with the AIDS virus, but the virus died. They have shown that bugs can retain hepatitis B virus for weeks, but when they bite chimpanzees, the infection does not take. Brazilian researchers have come closest, getting bedbugs to transfer the Chagas parasite from a wild mouse to lab mice.
?Someday, somebody may come along with a better experiment,? Goddard said.
That lingering uncertainty has led to one change in lab practice. The classic bedbug strain that all newly caught bugs are compared against is a colony originally from Fort Dix, N.J., that a researcher kept alive for 30 years by letting it feed on him.
But Stephen A. Kells, a University of Minnesota entomologist, said he ?prefers not to play with that risk.?
He feeds his bugs expired blood-bank blood through parafilm, which he describes as ?waxy Saran Wrap.?
Coby Schal of North Carolina State said he formerly used condoms with rabbit blood, but switched to parafilm because his condom budget raised eyebrows with university auditors.
Why the bugs disappeared for so long and exploded so fast after they reappeared is another question. The conventional answer - that DDT was banned - is inadequate. After all, mosquitoes, roaches and other insects rebounded long ago.
Much has to do with the bugs? habits. Before central heating arrived in the early 1900s, they died back in winter. People who frequently re-stuffed their mattresses or dismantled their beds to pour on boiling water - easier for those with servants - suffered less, said bedbug historian Michael F. Potter of the University of Kentucky.
Early remedies were risky: igniting gunpowder on mattresses or soaking them with gasoline, fumigating buildings with burning sulfur or cyanide gas. (The best-known brand was Zyklon B, which later became infamous at Auschwitz.)
Success finally arrived in the 1950s as the bugs were hit first with DDT and then with malathion, diazinon, lindane, chlordane and dichlorovos, as resistance to each developed. In those days, mattresses were sprayed, DDT dust was sprinkled into the sheets, nurseries were lined with DDT-impregnated wallpaper.
In North America and Western Europe, ?the slate was virtually wiped clean,? said Potter, who has surveyed pest-control experts in 43 countries. In South America, the Middle East and Africa, populations fell but never vanished.
The bugs also persisted on domestic poultry farms and in a few human habitations.
One theory is that domestic bedbugs surged after pest control companies stopped spraying for Co*kroaches in the 1980s and switched to poisoned baits, which bedbugs do not eat.
But the prevailing theory is that new bugs were introduced from overseas, because the ones found in cities now are resistant to different insecticides from those used on poultry or Co*kroaches.
Exactly where they came from is a mystery. Schal is now building a ?world bedbug collection? and hopes to produce a global map of variations in their genes, which might answer the question.
Experts say they?ve heard blame pinned on many foreign ethnic groups and on historic events from the fall of the Berlin Wall to the Persian Gulf war to the spread of mosquito nets in Africa. Every theory has holes and many are simply racist.
(For example, Potter said, he has heard Mexicans blamed, but Mexican pest control companies he contacted said they rarely see the bugs except in the homes of people returning from the United States, often with scavenged furniture.)
Pest-control companies say hotels, especially airport business hotels and resorts attracting foreign tourists, had the first outbreaks, said both Potter and Richard Cooper, a pest-control spe...t.
Whatever the source, the future is grim, experts agreed.
Many pesticides don?t work, and some that do are banned - though whether people should fear the bug or the bug-killer more is open to debate.
?I?d like to take some of these groups and lock them in an apartment building full of bugs and see what they say then,? Potter said of environmentalists.
Treatment, including dismantling furniture and ripping up rugs, is expensive. Rather than actively hunting for bugs, hotels and landlords often deny having them.
Many people are not alert enough. (Both Cooper and Goddard said they routinely pull apart beds and even headboards when they check into hotels. Goddard keeps his luggage in the bathroom. Cooper heat-treats his when he gets home.)
Some people over-react, even developing delusional parasitosis, the illusion that bugs are crawling on them.
?People call me all the time, losing their minds, like it?s a curse from God,? Miller said.
The reasonable course, Goddard said, is to recognize that we are, in effect, back in the 1920s ?Sleep tight, don?t let the bedbugs bite? era. People should be aware, but not panicky.
However, he added, ?I don?t even know what to say about them being in theaters. That?s kind of spooky.?
Well, he was asked - can you feel them bite?
?No,? he said. ?If I put them on my arm and close my eyes, I never feel them. But I once got my children to put them on my face, and I did. Maybe there are more nerve endings.?
Why in the world, he was asked, would he ask kids to do that?
?Oh, you know,? he said. ?Bug people are crazy.?